Curated by Justin Bailey
In one sentence: The Gospel of Matthew is traditionally attributed to the apostle Matthew, but modern scholarship often questions this attribution.
Why it matters:
The authorship of the Gospel of Matthew is significant because it affects how readers interpret its content and authority. If an apostle wrote it, it might be considered a more direct witness to Jesus' life and teachings.
State of play:
The Gospel of Matthew is traditionally attributed to Matthew, one of Jesus’ twelve apostles, identified as a tax collector. This tradition comes from the early Christian writings and the patristic tradition, which suggest that Matthew himself wrote the gospel. The gospel itself is rich in Jewish symbolism and theology, reflecting a detailed knowledge of Jewish law and prophecy, which supports the idea that it was written by someone deeply familiar with Jewish customs.
Yes, but:
Modern biblical scholarship often challenges the direct authorship by Matthew for several reasons:
- Textual analysis: The gospel is primarily based on Mark’s Gospel and other sources, such as Q and possibly some unique material (termed "M"), which suggests Matthew may not have been an eyewitness to all the events he describes.
- Language and style: The original text is in Greek, which was not the first language of a Galilean Jew, leading some to suggest it might have been written or translated by a second-generation Christian.
- Historical context: The Gospel of Matthew was written between 80 and 90 AD, several decades after Jesus’ death, which raises questions about the possibility of an eyewitness account surviving in oral tradition before being written down.
What skeptics say:
Skeptics argue that the lack of original manuscripts and the anonymous nature of the text make it difficult to confirm the traditional attribution to Matthew. They see the gospel as a product of the early Christian community, shaped by its theological and pastoral needs rather than a firsthand historical account.
Between the lines:
The question of authorship might not diminish the theological and liturgical importance of the Gospel of Matthew for many believers. Its teachings, parables, and narrative structure have significantly shaped Christian doctrine and practice, regardless of its author.
Zoom out:
The debate over the authorship of the Gospel of Matthew is part of a broader discussion on the origins and authenticity of religious texts. It highlights the interplay between faith, history, and textual analysis in religious scholarship.
The bottom line:
While the apostle Matthew is traditionally credited with writing the gospel that bears his name, there is considerable scholarly debate about this attribution, focusing on textual evidence and historical context. The true identity of the author may remain an open question, but the impact and importance of the Gospel of Matthew in Christian tradition are undisputed.
Follow Up Questions
What are the primary sources or early Christian writings that attribute the Gospel of Matthew to the apostle Matthew? (Coming Soon)
How do the themes of Jewish law and prophecy in the Gospel of Matthew support the tradition of Matthean authorship? (Coming Soon)
What is the Q source, and how does it relate to the Gospel of Matthew's reliance on other texts like Mark's Gospel? (Coming Soon)
Can you explain the significance of the Gospel of Matthew being written in Greek in relation to its authorship? (Coming Soon)
How do the historical and cultural contexts of the late first century influence the content and themes of the Gospel of Matthew? (Coming Soon)
What are the theological and pastoral needs of the early Christian community that may have shaped the Gospel of Matthew? (Coming Soon)
How does the lack of original manuscripts impact the study and interpretation of the Gospel of Matthew? (Coming Soon)
In what ways has the Gospel of Matthew influenced Christian doctrine and practice, irrespective of its authorship? (Coming Soon)
What are the broader implications of the debate over the authenticity of religious texts like the Gospel of Matthew for religious scholarship? (Coming Soon)
Considering the scholarly debates, what criteria are used to evaluate the authorship of ancient religious texts? (Coming Soon)
Justin Bailey – Creator of ChristianAnswers.ai
All answers are curated and manually reviewed prior to being posted. Multiple language models are used to assist with verification.